western healBBC News – Pensioner wins legal bid over cuts to cleaning service
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser， you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.
The 75-year-old， who lives alone in supported housing at an undisclosed address， has impaired mobility and limited social contact.
A wheelchair-using pensioner has won a legal challenge over the withdrawal of clewestern healthaning services at her specially-adapted bungalow.
"I consider that， from the point of the crossroads which was reached in August/September 2008， the trust has proceeded on the assumption that Mrs McClean is well able to afford the cost of domestic cleaning services.
"However， there is no evidence whatsoever of any proper consideration of Mrs McClean&039;s income."
He held that it had also "impermissibly" taken into account the pensioner&039;s disability-related benefits.
Mrs McClean was said to lead a solitary existence， with her son and care assistants being the only regular visitors.
Mr Justice McCloskey added: "I have opted for this particular remedy on the premise that it will stimulate a reassessment of Mrs McClean&039;s needs which will entail a full inquiry into all material cts and considerations and fresh， fully informed decisions. This will hopefully ensue promptly."
"This has given rise to a significant strain on her limited financial resources and all of this has been the cause of resulting distress and worry，" the judge said.
She challenged the adequacy of the trust&039;s social care provision to her.
Mrs McClean also received cleaning help， involving carpet vacuuming， and washing kitchen and bathroom floors， for one and a half hours a week until it was withdrawn in 2008.
The judge made a declaration that in withdrawing her cleaning service the trust acted unlawfully by iling to ensure all information and considerations were taken into account.
She claimed the withdrawal was unlawful and has led to her spending up to 48 a week on cleaning services.
In his judgment， Mr Justice McCloskey said: "It is clear from all the evidence that Mrs McClean is a proud and independent lady who wishes to preserve her independence， privacy and dignity for as long as possible."
Daily services， provided to her on the basis of a trust assessment， included help in dressing， preparing breakst， lunch and dinner， applying cream to her legs and evening assistance.
Ruling that her application for judicial review should succeed， he pointed out how western healBBC News – Pensioner wins legal bid over cuts to cleaning serviceshe had had to fund cleaning services for more than two years.
The 51-year-old woman who was shot dead in Portstewart， County Londonderry， on Friday was Marion Millican.
It is clear from all the evidence that Mrs McClean is a proud and independent lady who wishes to preserve her independence， privacy and dignity for as long as possible.
western healBBC News – Pensioner wins legal bid over cuts to cleaning service，Kathleen McClean brought judicial review proceedings against the Western Health and Social Care Trust.